•  
  •  
 

Level of Education

Undergraduate

Abstract

This paper examines whether Augustine of Hippo and Marcus Tullius Cicero stand in genuine opposition or whether their political thought rests on a shared anthropological foundation. The standard reading places them on opposite sides of the divide between pagan antiquity and Christian theology, with Augustine's City of God read as a wholesale rejection of the Ciceronian republic. I argue the opposite. A close reading of De Re Publica, De Officiis, De Civitate Dei, and De Libero Arbitrio shows that the two thinkers converge on three claims: human nature is structurally disordered by self-love, political institutions must be calibrated to that disorder rather than to imagined virtue, and justice is intelligible only when ordered to an end higher than the political community itself. Drawing on Alasdair MacIntyre's account of tradition-constituted inquiry and Oliver O'Donovan's political theology, the paper develops this convergence as the deepest intellectual layer of the Christian-republican synthesis that runs through Aquinas, the magisterial Reformers, and the American founding. The hypothesis holds. The apparent opposition between Augustine and Cicero is largely a function of theological vocabulary and emphasis, not substantive disagreement. Ecclesiastes 1:9 names the pattern: "There is nothing new under the sun."

(208 words)

Share

COinS