•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI, continues to reshape higher education, introducing ethical challenges involving instructional practices, assessment, academic integrity, and student learning. This qualitative study employed a narrative-informed, open-ended survey to examine how higher education faculty described their ethical decision-making experiences and perceived ethical leadership responsibilities related to AI integration in instructional practice. Guided by Kohlberg's moral development theory, the study explored the moral reasoning underlying faculty instructional decisions. Nine faculty members from three higher education institutions participated, and their de-identified written responses were analyzed using a hybrid deductive-inductive thematic approach. Six themes emerged: values-based moral reasoning; authentic learning over substitution; contextual accountability and restoration; ethical leadership through modeling and guidance; policy and training as ethical infrastructure; and equity, access, and AI literacy. Participants described navigating ethical tensions between acceptable AI assistance and substitution for independent student work while balancing academic accountability with opportunities for correction under varying institutional expectations. The findings illustrate how faculty considered integrity, fairness, institutional guidance, and authentic student learning when explaining their ethical decisions. Although limited to nine self-reported accounts, the study contributes to higher education and organizational leadership by providing insight into faculty moral reasoning and ethical considerations that may inform institutional guidance, faculty development, and responsible AI implementation.

Included in

Business Commons

Share

COinS