•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Unconscious bias is a pervasive cognitive phenomenon that influences leadership perception, judgment, and decision-making. While prior research has emphasized its negative consequences in organizational systems, limited attention has been given to how leaders intentionally engage and navigate bias within real-world decision contexts. This qualitative single-case study explored how leaders within a participating public school district (the study district) navigate unconscious bias to improve leadership decision-making in talent management and organizational practice. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews, an online questionnaire, survey responses, and archival documentation to support methodological triangulation. Four central themes emerged: unconscious bias is inevitable but navigable; experience deepens reflective engagement with bias; intentional bias mitigation strengthens trust and organizational credibility; and unconscious bias can function as a decision heuristic when applied intentionally. The findings suggest that effective leaders do not eliminate unconscious bias but engage it reflectively through structured decision practices, ethical leadership behaviors, and organizational accountability mechanisms. The study further introduces the Reflective Leadership Navigation Framework (RLNF) and the Five Reflective Navigation Principles (R²VDL) as additional conceptual outcomes derived from the approved findings. These findings offer practical guidance for leaders seeking to balance timely decisions with fairness, emphasizing reflective judgment, transparent procedures, and continuous learning while recognizing the contextual limits of evidence drawn from one specific organizational setting.

Included in

Business Commons

Share

COinS