Date
4-7-2026
Department
Rawlings School of Divinity
Degree
Doctor of Ministry (DMin)
Chair
John Peterson
Keywords
church leadership, discipleship, leadership development, leadership succession, mentoring, Pauline discipleship, spiritual formation
Disciplines
Leadership Studies | Practical Theology
Recommended Citation
Beagle, Matthew Scott, "Mentorship Leadership Succession: Implementing Paul's Discipleship Practices" (2026). Doctoral Dissertations and Projects. 8095.
https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/8095
Abstract
This action research project addresses the lack of empowered, biblically qualified leaders at Pinecrest Baptist Church in Portsmouth, VA, where discipleship has often been treated as complete with conversion, baptism, and initial ministry involvement, rather than as a process that produces future leaders within the congregation. The project proposed that a mentor-based discipleship succession process, modeled on Pauline discipleship, could help current leaders shift from a maintenance mindset to a culture of multiplication and leadership development. Using an action research design, the study implemented a twelve-week mentor-discipleship succession curriculum that guided participants through four phases of leadership development: calling that comes with conversion, equipping leaders, empowering leaders, and leaving a kingdom legacy through multiplication. Participants included lay leaders serving as mentors and selected mentees who demonstrated biblical qualifications and leadership potential. Data was collected through pre-, reflective, and post-intervention Likert-scale assessments, spiritual gift inventories, and qualitative analysis of homework and narrative reflections from interviews. Results indicated measurable growth in assurance of calling, confidence in leadership, mentor readiness, relational trust, and biblical leadership among mentors and mentees. The intervention resulted in the placement of mentees in specific leadership roles within PBC, establishing a foundation for a sustainable leadership pipeline. These findings support the thesis that a Pauline-modeled mentor curriculum can foster spiritual formation and leadership succession and prove a model for other congregations facing similar challenges.
