Location

Liberty University

Event Website

https://www.liberty.edu/business/sport-leadership/

Start Date

2-11-2026 12:00 AM

End Date

3-11-2026 12:00 AM

Description

This research proposal investigates some of the factors that play a role in why statistically dominant and highly touted collegiate quarterbacks fail to replicate the same statistical dominance in the NFL. For this research proposal, we plan to use a quantitative approach, looking into the statistics of our chosen quarterbacks. We understand the limitations of our research method, namely that some factors, such as work ethic or mentorship, can’t be measured, but we hope to avoid personal bias by looking at the concrete stats. In our research proposal, we will compare three quarterbacks’ (Johnny Manziel, Josh Rosen, Mitchell Trubisky) collegiate stats against their NFL stats, which show a visible drop-off in every statistic. Past studies show that some of the reasons these quarterbacks fail are also related to management, whether that be the coaching or the lack of a veteran quarterback mentor. Our hypothesis is that the many demands of the NFL, such as playstyle, skill level, coaching, and mentorship, all play a pivotal role in why these quarterbacks struggle to excel in the NFL as they did in college. Because NFL organizations pour so much money, resources, and time into players at this position, we hope this research proposal will help NFL organizations learn, when drafting their future quarterbacks, how to give them the best chance to succeed, thus helping the NFL grow further as a brand and product.

Share

COinS
 
Nov 2nd, 12:00 AM Nov 3rd, 12:00 AM

An Examination of the Factors that Prevented Statistically Dominant College Quarterbacks from Replicating their Success in the NFL

Liberty University

This research proposal investigates some of the factors that play a role in why statistically dominant and highly touted collegiate quarterbacks fail to replicate the same statistical dominance in the NFL. For this research proposal, we plan to use a quantitative approach, looking into the statistics of our chosen quarterbacks. We understand the limitations of our research method, namely that some factors, such as work ethic or mentorship, can’t be measured, but we hope to avoid personal bias by looking at the concrete stats. In our research proposal, we will compare three quarterbacks’ (Johnny Manziel, Josh Rosen, Mitchell Trubisky) collegiate stats against their NFL stats, which show a visible drop-off in every statistic. Past studies show that some of the reasons these quarterbacks fail are also related to management, whether that be the coaching or the lack of a veteran quarterback mentor. Our hypothesis is that the many demands of the NFL, such as playstyle, skill level, coaching, and mentorship, all play a pivotal role in why these quarterbacks struggle to excel in the NFL as they did in college. Because NFL organizations pour so much money, resources, and time into players at this position, we hope this research proposal will help NFL organizations learn, when drafting their future quarterbacks, how to give them the best chance to succeed, thus helping the NFL grow further as a brand and product.

https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/sport-leadership/Presentations/2026/2

 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.