Start Date

2-11-2026 12:00 AM

End Date

2-11-2026 12:00 AM

Description

This study investigates whether artificial intelligence (AI) assistance can help Division I college football coaches develop more effective, individualized coaching plans than coaching plans created without the use of AI assistance. While AI is used more prevalently at the professional level (e.g., NFL’s Next Gen Stats), it remains to be seen whether and how AI assistance can help with the creation of coaching plans at the Division I collegiate level. This study asks, “How does the use of AI-powered analysis contribute to the effectiveness of personalized coaching plans created by D-I college football coaches?” The study will be completed using a quasi-experimental design with a sample of 20-40 D-I football coaches with 3+ years of experience. Coaches will be grouped by their experience level, and then stratified random assignment will be used to create the AI-assisted and non-AI-assisted groups. Each participating coach will be given the same standardized athlete profile, film, and data. These coaches will then be provided a computer and other office equipment to create their coaching plans. Coaches using AI will be allowed to modify, accept, or reject AI-generated insights and will have final say over the completed plan. Independent evaluators, unaware of whether each plan came from the AI or non-AI condition, will then be provided with the completed plans and will score them on a standardized effectiveness rubric on a 1-10 scale; these scores will be averaged to give each plan an effectiveness score. The results will then be compared to determine whether the AI-assisted plans are more effective than, less effective than, or as effective as the non-AI-assisted plans. Future research could be developed as AI continues to grow in its usefulness and applications.

Share

COinS
 
Nov 2nd, 12:00 AM Nov 2nd, 12:00 AM

Can AI Create More Effective Coaching Plans in D-I College Football?

This study investigates whether artificial intelligence (AI) assistance can help Division I college football coaches develop more effective, individualized coaching plans than coaching plans created without the use of AI assistance. While AI is used more prevalently at the professional level (e.g., NFL’s Next Gen Stats), it remains to be seen whether and how AI assistance can help with the creation of coaching plans at the Division I collegiate level. This study asks, “How does the use of AI-powered analysis contribute to the effectiveness of personalized coaching plans created by D-I college football coaches?” The study will be completed using a quasi-experimental design with a sample of 20-40 D-I football coaches with 3+ years of experience. Coaches will be grouped by their experience level, and then stratified random assignment will be used to create the AI-assisted and non-AI-assisted groups. Each participating coach will be given the same standardized athlete profile, film, and data. These coaches will then be provided a computer and other office equipment to create their coaching plans. Coaches using AI will be allowed to modify, accept, or reject AI-generated insights and will have final say over the completed plan. Independent evaluators, unaware of whether each plan came from the AI or non-AI condition, will then be provided with the completed plans and will score them on a standardized effectiveness rubric on a 1-10 scale; these scores will be averaged to give each plan an effectiveness score. The results will then be compared to determine whether the AI-assisted plans are more effective than, less effective than, or as effective as the non-AI-assisted plans. Future research could be developed as AI continues to grow in its usefulness and applications.

 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.