Category

Poster - Textual or Investigative

Description

For many, the American Transcendentalist movement carries a connotation of moral subjectivism. It seems only natural, as one of the defining features of the Transcendentalist movement is the emphasis placed on individual experience. However, is this truly the case? This project examines whether a subjectivist view is held by one of the movement’s integral figures, Ralph Waldo Emerson, in his Divinity School Address. This work was chosen because of its significance to the Transcendentalist movement, regarded as an accurate but concise compilation of Emerson’s fundamental assertions, and thus, an accurate representation of his general philosophy. This study was conducted by examining the nature of the ethical claims made in the Divinity School Address, discerning whether they assert a position of objective morality, and examining Emerson’s influences to discern the origin of his moral philosophy. When research was conducted in this manner, there were many instances of both objective and subjective ethical claims made in the Address; however, those that were subjective were only such insofar as subjective moral faculties, such as intuition, led one to objective morality. These ethical positions are also asserted by Immanuel Kant, one of Emerson’s influences. Study of Kant’s writings yielded possible insight into Emerson’s view of objective morality, especially as it pertains to one’s intuition. Thus, the conclusion of this study is that the Divinity School Address does not assert that morality is ultimately subjective as decided by one’s intuition, but that within one’s intuition is the ability to perceive the objective moral law. This study could imply a misinterpretation of Transcendentalist ethics more broadly and may necessitate further study into the ethical claims of other Transcendentalist works.

Comments

Undergraduate - 3rd Place Award Winner

Share

COinS
 
Apr 15th, 12:00 PM

Understanding the Sublime: Objective Morality in the Divinity School Address

Poster - Textual or Investigative

For many, the American Transcendentalist movement carries a connotation of moral subjectivism. It seems only natural, as one of the defining features of the Transcendentalist movement is the emphasis placed on individual experience. However, is this truly the case? This project examines whether a subjectivist view is held by one of the movement’s integral figures, Ralph Waldo Emerson, in his Divinity School Address. This work was chosen because of its significance to the Transcendentalist movement, regarded as an accurate but concise compilation of Emerson’s fundamental assertions, and thus, an accurate representation of his general philosophy. This study was conducted by examining the nature of the ethical claims made in the Divinity School Address, discerning whether they assert a position of objective morality, and examining Emerson’s influences to discern the origin of his moral philosophy. When research was conducted in this manner, there were many instances of both objective and subjective ethical claims made in the Address; however, those that were subjective were only such insofar as subjective moral faculties, such as intuition, led one to objective morality. These ethical positions are also asserted by Immanuel Kant, one of Emerson’s influences. Study of Kant’s writings yielded possible insight into Emerson’s view of objective morality, especially as it pertains to one’s intuition. Thus, the conclusion of this study is that the Divinity School Address does not assert that morality is ultimately subjective as decided by one’s intuition, but that within one’s intuition is the ability to perceive the objective moral law. This study could imply a misinterpretation of Transcendentalist ethics more broadly and may necessitate further study into the ethical claims of other Transcendentalist works.

 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.